FHA vs Conventional Loan Calculator
FHA and conventional loans handle mortgage insurance in completely different ways, and that difference can matter more than the interest rate itself. This calculator compares both loan types at the same home price and down payment, showing the full monthly payment and the total mortgage insurance cost for each.
lower per month, principal, interest, tax, insurance, and mortgage insurance all included
The FHA loan runs $2,761 a month, the conventional loan runs $2,776 a month, a difference of $16. The insurance behind those numbers behaves very differently over time:
- •This assumes you finance the $5,911 FHA upfront mortgage insurance premium, which is already rolled into that FHA loan amount and monthly payment.
- •At 3.5% down, FHA mortgage insurance does not cancel, it runs for the full 30 years and totals $56,704 over the life of the loan.
- •Conventional PMI cancels automatically once you reach 20% equity, projected at month 134, for a total of about $20,743 paid before it drops off.
FHA loans accept lower credit scores and a smaller down payment, which is why they often win for buyers still building credit, even with mortgage insurance that runs longer. Conventional loans usually win for buyers with strong credit and 20% down, since they have no mortgage insurance at all in that case. Actual rates and eligibility depend on your own credit profile, confirm both with a lender before deciding.
A free account keeps your numbers ready across every calculator, no re entering them each time.
How this calculator works
- Step 1Enter the loan basics
Home price, down payment, and term, shared across both loan types.
- Step 2Enter each rate
FHA and conventional rates are often different, both are editable.
- Step 3See the real tradeoff
Monthly payment for each, plus how long each type of mortgage insurance actually lasts.
Frequently asked questions
What is the biggest difference between FHA and conventional mortgage insurance?
FHA mortgage insurance premium, MIP, usually cannot be cancelled once your down payment is under 10%, it runs for the entire life of the loan. Conventional private mortgage insurance, PMI, only applies below 20% down and cancels automatically once you reach 20% equity, which this calculator estimates for you.
Why would anyone choose FHA if the insurance lasts longer?
FHA loans accept lower credit scores and a smaller minimum down payment than most conventional programs, which makes homeownership reachable sooner for buyers still building credit. The longer lasting insurance is a real tradeoff for that lower bar to qualify, not a hidden cost.
Can I refinance out of FHA mortgage insurance later?
Yes, refinancing into a conventional loan once you have built enough equity and improved your credit is a common way to end FHA MIP earlier than the loan term would otherwise allow. That refinance comes with its own closing costs and rate, worth running through the refinance calculators here before deciding.
Does a bigger down payment change the FHA versus conventional comparison?
Substantially. At 20% down, conventional loans have no mortgage insurance at all, which usually makes them the cheaper option outright if your credit qualifies. FHA loans still charge mortgage insurance even at 20% down or more, so the gap between the two options narrows or reverses as the down payment grows.
Are FHA interest rates always lower than conventional rates?
Often, but not always, FHA rates tend to run slightly lower since the loan is government insured, but the total monthly payment still depends heavily on the mortgage insurance cost layered on top. This calculator lets you enter each rate separately so the comparison reflects real current offers rather than an assumption.
Do I have to finance the FHA upfront mortgage insurance premium, or can I pay it in cash?
You can do either. Financing it into the loan is more common since it needs no extra cash at closing, but it does raise your loan amount and monthly payment slightly. Paying it in cash keeps your loan amount and monthly payment lower at the cost of that much more upfront. This calculator lets you pick either one.
More home buying calculators
Your estimated monthly payment, broken into principal, interest, tax, and insurance.
A realistic home price based on your income, debts, and down payment.
A short check on credit, savings, and debt that scores how ready you are to buy.
Every number on this page is a planning estimate, for informational and educational purposes only, not professional advice.
Before you act on any major decisions, consult a qualified accountant, tax advisor, or financial advisor who knows your full picture.